Proprietary Estoppel Solicitors
Have you been promised property, land or an interest in an estate, but that promise has not been fulfilled? If you've made significant decisions or sacrifices in reliance on that promise, you may have grounds to pursue a proprietary estoppel claim.
Our proprietary estoppel solicitors can help you understand your legal position, assess the evidence and explore your options for resolving the dispute.
We also act for executors, beneficiaries and property owners who are facing a claim, helping them respond with confidence.
We work with clients across Liverpool, Warrington, Runcorn, Wigan and the wider North West, as well as remotely throughout England and Wales.
Call 03444 124348 or enquire today.
What Is Proprietary Estoppel?
Proprietary estoppel is a legal principle that can be used to stop someone from going back on earlier promises to transfer property or land.
For example, you could have been told that you would inherit your family’s farm in the future and made important decisions based on that. If this promise is later withdrawn, you may have grounds for a claim.
Whether a claim is successful will depend on the evidence available, including the nature of the promise, how much you relied on it, and any resulting detriment.
The Key Elements of a Proprietary Estoppel Claim
There are three core principles involved when submitting a proprietary estoppel claim: assurance, reliance, and detriment. Here’s what they entail:
- Assurance: You were made a promise about receiving property or land.
- Reliance: You relied on this promise and acted, or didn’t act, because of it.
- Detriment: You suffered a disadvantage as a result, such as financial costs, unpaid work, or giving up opportunities.
Based on these factors, the court will consider whether it would be unfair to allow the property owner to deny the expectation they created when the claimant has relied on it to their detriment.
When Can You Make a Proprietary Estoppel Claim?
So, you know what assurance, reliance, and detriment mean, but what could these look like in practice? Proprietary estoppel claims can arise in a range of circumstances, including:
| Situation | What this could involve |
|---|---|
| Involvement in family farms or businesses | Working on a family farm or business for many years after being given an assurance that you would eventually inherit a share. |
| Providing care and financial contributions | Providing care for someone or contributing financially towards a property after being led to believe you would receive an interest in it. |
| Changing your position | Giving up career opportunities, relocating, or making other significant life decisions because of an assurance about property or land. |
| Cohabiting couples | Your partner making a clear promise about property ownership, which you relied on to your detriment. |
These are just some examples, and every case is different. A promise on its own doesn’t guarantee a successful claim. The circumstances surrounding the assurance, your reliance on it, and any detriment will all need to be considered.
What Evidence Will You Need?
Providing evidence is very important in proprietary estoppel claims, particularly when the promise was spoken.
Evidence examples include, but are not limited to:
- Documents: Letters, emails, text messages, previous wills, or other correspondence referring to the promise.
- Financial and work records: Bank statements, tax records, payslips, or other records showing money spent on the property or work carried out.
- Other records: Photographs, planning applications, or any other documents showing your involvement with the property or land.
- Witness statements: Accounts from family members, neighbours, colleagues, or anyone else who heard the assurance.
We can help gather and assess them to demonstrate that it would be unconscionable for the other party to go back on their promise.
Remedies for Proprietary Estoppel
If a claim is successful, the court will decide what remedy is appropriate.
Following the Supreme Court’s decision in Guest v Guest (2022), the court’s starting point is usually to satisfy the claimant's expectations as opposed to compensate for any financial detriment.
The remedy must be proportionate, and depending on the circumstances, this may include:
- Transfer of a property
- Right to occupy the property
- Financial compensation
- An interest in the property
Defending a Proprietary Estoppel Claim
Receiving a proprietary estoppel claim can be unsettling, especially if it comes from a family member or arrives while you’re grieving. We’ll give you clear, honest advice on the strength of the claim and the best way to respond
Common Grounds for Defending a Claim
Every case is different, but defences often focus on one or more of the following:
| Ground | What this could involve |
|---|---|
| No clear assurance | The comments relied on were vague, casual or aspirational, rather than a promise the claimant could reasonably rely on. |
| Conditional or changed promises | The promise depended on something that didn’t happen, or circumstances changed in a way both sides understood. |
| No reliance | The claimant would have made the same decisions anyway, for their own reasons. |
| No real detriment | Any sacrifices were outweighed by benefits received, such as rent-free living, wages, a share of profits or financial support. |
| A disproportionate claim | Even if some claim exists, what’s being asked for goes far beyond what would be fair. |
If You’re an Executor
As an executor, you have a duty to administer the estate properly and protect it for all beneficiaries.
When a claim is made, you’ll usually need to pause distributions until it’s resolved, consider your position carefully, and avoid steps that could expose you to personal liability.
We can advise you on your responsibilities and help you respond in a way that protects both the estate and you.
If You’re a Beneficiary or Property Owner
If your inheritance or your property is at risk, we’ll help you understand how the claim could affect you and what you can do about it. That includes gathering evidence of what was actually said and agreed, any benefits the claimant received, and the wider family circumstances.
How Our Proprietary Estoppel Solicitors Can Help
We understand how devastating it can be to feel that a promise you relied on hasn’t been honoured. Our proprietary estoppel solicitors will give you clear, honest advice and help you understand your options.
- Reviewing your circumstances: Our team will take the time to understand what happened, including what was promised, how it was relied on, and any detriment claimed. If you’re defending a claim, we’ll assess its strengths and weaknesses from the outset.
- Gathering evidence: We’ll help you identify and gather appropriate evidence to support your position, whether that shows a clear promise was made or that the claim doesn’t stand up.
- Preparing or responding to a letter of claim: We’ll prepare a letter of claim to the person who made the promise or, if they’ve died, the executors of their estate. If you’ve received a letter of claim, we’ll prepare a detailed response setting out your position.
- Advising executors: If you’re an executor, we’ll guide you through your duties while a claim is ongoing, helping you protect the estate and avoid personal liability.
- Negotiation or mediation: We’ll look to resolve the dispute without the additional time and cost of court proceedings, aiming for a fair outcome that, where possible, preserves family relationships.
- Representing you in court: If the dispute can’t be resolved, we’ll represent you through court proceedings, whether you’re bringing the claim or defending it.
We’ll keep you informed throughout the process and explain what to expect at each stage of your claim. Get in touch to discuss your circumstances and find out how we can help.
How Much Does a Proprietary Estoppel Claim Cost?
The cost of a proprietary estoppel claim will depend on the complexity of the dispute, the evidence, and whether the matter can be resolved without court proceedings.
We offer a fixed-fee initial meeting and hourly rates, depending on the work involved. For more details, contact us today.
Why Choose Bell Lamb & Joynson
At Bell Lamb & Joynson, we don’t just provide expert legal advice. We’re committed to delivering outstanding client care, too. Our team prioritises clear communication and responsiveness, ensuring you have the support you need throughout your case.
Established over 200 years ago, we have a long history of helping clients with complex legal matters. We’re also recognised as a Legal 500 Leading Firm (2026), reflecting the quality of our work.
Whether you’re bringing a claim or defending one, contact us on 03444 124348 or complete our enquiry form.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between promissory estoppel and proprietary estoppel?
Both principles can prevent someone from going back on a promise, but they apply in different situations. Promissory estoppel relates to an existing legal relationship, like a landlord and tenant, and may be used as a defence. Proprietary estoppel, on the other hand, concerns assurances about property or land and can be used to make a legal claim.
Does the promise have to be in writing to make a proprietary estoppel claim?
A proprietary estoppel promise does not have to be in writing. It can be spoken, but you’ll need to provide evidence of what was assured. This could include witness statements from family members, neighbours, or colleagues.
Can I make a claim while the person who promised is still alive?
A proprietary estoppel claim can be made while the person who made the promise is still alive, for example, if they’ve told you they’ve changed their mind or have given the property to someone else. Most claims arise after death, but a lifetime claim is possible if you can show assurance, reliance, and detriment.
How long does a proprietary estoppel claim take?
As a general guide, an out-of-court settlement may take around 3 to 12 months, while contested litigation or a trial can take 18 to 24 months, potentially longer. Where possible, negotiating a settlement can help avoid the additional time and expense involved in going to trial.
Can I make a proprietary estoppel claim and an Inheritance Act claim together?
Yes, it’s possible to bring proprietary estoppel and Inheritance Act claims together, but they’re based on different legal principles. Proprietary estoppel focuses on an assurance about property or land, while a claim under the Inheritance Act considers whether a will or the rules of intestacy have failed to make reasonable financial provision for you. If you have grounds for both, we can advise you on your options.
Is there a time limit for a proprietary estoppel and Inheritance Act claim?
There’s no fixed time limit for proprietary estoppel. However, delaying without good reason may make it more difficult to gather evidence and runs the risk that the asset in question has already been distributed. It’s best to get advice as soon as you become aware the promise won’t be honoured. If you’re also considering an Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 claim, you’ll usually need to apply within six months of the grant of representation.